Antagonists in Our Discernments

04E 2 choiceAs we look through our life with a storytelling lens, we might ask ourselves: do good followers of Jesus have antagonists?

Yes, we do!

Keep in mind that antagonist doesn’t mean villain or enemy, although in a story they might be. Rather, an antagonist is anyone or anything that stands in the way to the protagonist achieving his or her goals. An antagonist can be an enemy, but doesn’t need to be, as an antagonist can oppose our goal for many reasons (their reasons may be good or bad or neutral). An antagonist may not even be a person but force, and have no reason at all. In my experience, many of us have antagonists but few of us have the kinds of real enemies or villains that we see in the movies.

It’s helpful to think about how we, as followers of Jesus, may want to respond to those people in our lives who, in some way, distract us from or stand in the way of our discernment. (Later, we’ll look at other obstacles to discerning.)

In addition to a loving relationship with God, the most important condition for a genuine discernment is freedom: freedom to hear God’s invitation, and freedom to choose how to respond. The people in our lives can either help us towards freedom, or block our journey to freedom. Yet, even when someone seems to “block” our discernment and our freedom, their antagonism may be the resistance we need to discover a deeper freedom. Their resistance may also push us to a new level of commitment in seeking God’s will.

For example, Joe, a husband and father, is discerning if God is calling him to move from his current stable job to a new kind of work—perhaps as an entrepreneur doing the kind of work that has always been his dream. The people in Joe’s life will be important in his discernment. His wife, his parents, his friends, his children, his co-workers—each person will have his or her own idea about what Joe should do. Their ideas may be motivated by love for Joe, selfish concerns, or a mix of any number of motives, ranging from the desire for support and stability for his family, to fear of the new or unknown, doubts in an unproven ability, a desire to maintain the status quo, etc. Most likely Joe’s wife will have the most important role and influence—she has a unique prominence in Joe’s discernment as his wife. Ideally, Joe and his wife will discern God’s will for their family together.

Let’s suppose that, while Joe’s wife is fearful of how a change of work will affect their family’s financial stability, she loves Joe and shares his faith, so she supports his discernment. But a close friend—perhaps someone who has always been Joe’s strongest support—is adamant that Joe should continue doing exactly what he’s doing. Joe respects his friend’s opinion, and owes him alot for the support he has given to Joe and his family in the past. What does Joe do with the friend’s unhelpful advice and expectations?

It’s pretty clear that, as an adult responsible to God, his wife, and his children for living his life and call, Joe cannot simply listen to his friend blindly, even though their friendship means a lot to him. This friend is not just not helping Joe discern; the friend is antagonistic to Joe’s discernment, and has become a force against discerning at all. How does Joe handle this so that he can freely discern?

Depending on their friendship, Joe may use his friend’s negative response to explore his own feelings and motivations—whether during or after their conversations. After several attempts at discussion—perhaps after his second or tenth conversation—Joe might simply want to close this topic with his friend until he has completed his discernment. He may even call or visit his friend a little less frequently so that he is able to detach somewhat from the pressure of his expectations. Note that the friend’s resistance to Joe’s desire to discern can actually help him to focus and deepen his own reflection.

(Also note that it’s not the relationship itself that ends; Joe simply tries to put an end to fruitless discussion about his discernment. While there may be cases where we decide that it’s better to end a relationship or put it on hold so that we can freely discern, this usually has more to do with how the relationship has been developing, rather than the discernment itself. The discernment just becomes the “breaking point” where a shift or end of a relationship is recognized is inevitable.)

In any discernment, we want to choose carefully when and with whom we share our journey. We need the input of others, but we also need to be free to hear and listen to the other ways that God might be speaking to us—especiallyl interiorly. This is especially true for a young person discerning a vocation to marriage, religious life, priesthood, or single life, as pressures are sure to arise from all directions. Many people don’t understand well the vocation to priesthood or religious life, which makes it hard for them to be supportive even when they want to be.

For a number of reasons, I didn’t share my discernment journey with too many people—just several sisters and a few family members. But afterwards, when I shared my decision to enter religious life with family and friends, I was sometimes surprised by their reactions. Some friends whom I thought wouldn’t understand were supportive, pleased at how happy I was. Others—relatives who were faithful Catholics—surprised me by strongly opposing my decision, expressing concern that I was “wasting my life” by choosing religious life. Some of them tried to pressure me to change my mind.

Everyone with whom we are connected can influence our discernment. People can be supportive, cautionary, resistant, encouraging…the responses are as varied as the people you know. Choosing how and when to share our discernment, and with whom, is what we will explore next.


4 thoughts on “Antagonists in Our Discernments

  1. I am going through a significant discernment process right now having to do with a long-time goal and vision. I believe I may be discerning that I am not called to realize this vision . Colleagues are praying with me to discern God’s will for the project. I mentioned that as we pray, we should be open to the idea that God is not calling us to this. One person responded that this must be the Evil One at work tempting me to give up. I am considering this. It also occurs to me that she — the one acting as an antagonist to me — indeed MAY be called to continue on with the vision, and that I am reluctant to turn over leadership of “my project” to others who have not “proven” to me or to themselves the ability to lead .

    In the religious life, there are authorities to obey. Yet there are also questions of placement of personnel and questions of leadership. What helps for discernment about leadership or project feasibility exist in religious life? What happens if a sister is in a role or pursuing a goal when she begins to discern it may not be what God is calling her to?


    • Rae, thanks for your comments and insights. How true it is that often, in our world today with so many opportunities, we are discerning “nots”–that God might not be calling me to do this particular project. (This is sometimes where my personal discernments lead–that God is not calling me to take on more, but to do well what I am already doing.) I will keep your discernment in prayer–as it sounds like you are on a good path with self-knowledge, insight, and a gradual detaching from the demands of ego…

      In religious life, we have the additional help of the gift of authority of our religious superiors and our vow of obedience to help us to discern. Often, that makes our discernment easier. But sometimes, it makes our discernment much more challenging. Several times I have been in the situation that you hint at–where I feel that God is calling me to a particular aspect of our mission as Daughters of Saint Paul, but the superior has assigned me to something else. (She usually agrees with me that it’s a good idea, but often it becomes a matter of what is more of a priority in her eyes.) In these situations, I pray and discern about it first, before even speaking to the superior. But then I will speak to her about it as soon as it’s possible. If I don’t receive permission to go forward with what I feel God is calling me to, and I continue to feel strongly about it, I will probably go back to the superior several times. Oftentimes, together we can find a way to begin the “new project” even while I am working in my current assignment. Other times, after I discuss it with her and feel that I have expressed it well, if she really says “no,” then I simply entrust it to God. Sometimes it’s simply a matter of waiting for six months or a year…or a couple of years. In this case, I can begin to prepare for the new project with prayer and study, so that when the time arrives and my superior is able to say “yes,” I am ready to go forward quickly.

      The vows of chastity, poverty, and obedience require a deep, lived, and practical faith. It’s not always easy to see God’s will in the superior’s conviction…and yet, that is how we are asked to live our vow of obedience. When I disagree with the superior about priorities, I often find that Jesus is calling me to grow…in faith, in trust, in self-sacrifice, in patience, or in…whatever virtue I seem to be lacking. The vow of obedience isn’t easy, but it IS a way that ensures that we are frequently detaching from our own will, which radically increases the probability that we will grow more attached to God’s will! Which is the whole point of the vow of obedience–to cling to the Father’s will as Jesus did.


  2. Also, it seems to me that married couples may be called to follow goals and missions specific to the charism of marriage . But those charisms are not nearly so well defined as charisms in the various religious families. Maybe each marriage & family has its own unique charism, like each religious family .


    • Yes, I agree that every married couple and family have their own specific way of living their vocations! I don’t know if I’d call it a charism in the strictest sense, but I would in the sense that each family is called to uniquely live/witness to a particular aspect of God’s love in the world–in a way that no one else can. I believe that each person is called to this as well… And I love the complementarity between religious life, priesthood, and married/family life!


Share your thoughts and insights!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.